Episode 9 of "My Life with the Walter Boys Season 1" opens with Jackie heading off to an event, leaving some unresolved issues behind. Upon her return, she discovers that Alex is upset with her for not heeding his advice in the previous episode and pursuing Cole. In an effort to reconcile with Alex, Jackie explains that her actions were to assist Katherine with Cole, rather than for Cole himself. This clarification helps Jackie and Alex to resolve their misunderstanding and repair their relationship.

Elsewhere, Hayley visits the Walters' residence to address the tensions between her and Will. Their conversation leads to a resolution, and they agree to plan a modest wedding at the family farm, bringing a sense of harmony back into their relationship.

The episode also delves into the strained relationship between Erin and Olivia. Despite Olivia's ongoing apologies, Erin remains indifferent, unable to easily move past their issues. Concurrently, Jackie receives an enticing opportunity as a Princeton alumnus offers her an internship and invites her for an interview.

However, tensions flare up again during a horse racing event when Alex's horse loses due to a broken leash. Alex accuses Cole of negligence, leading to an argument that brings up unresolved issues from their past. Eventually, the brothers manage to set aside their differences, opening up to each other and finding common ground. In a turn of events, Alex receives an intriguing offer from a spectator who was impressed by his performance in the match.

Later, Cole picks Jackie up from her interview, while Alex, who had been eagerly waiting for Jackie at the fair, ends up crossing paths with his ex-girlfriend, Paige. This encounter allows Alex to confront Paige about their past, helping him to finally let go of lingering feelings and find closure.

However, the episode takes another dramatic turn when Cole and Jackie get stranded in the middle of nowhere due to a car breakdown on their way to the fair. Cole reaches out to Will for assistance, leading to Will and Alex coming to their rescue.

In the concluding moments of the episode, Cole takes the opportunity to clarify his feelings to Jackie, confessing that he has developed feelings for her. The episode ends with Alex and Will arriving to pick up Jackie and Cole, leaving viewers in suspense about the future dynamics of this love triangle.

Overall, episode 9 navigates through a series of emotional reconciliations and revelations, highlighting the complex relationships among the characters. While the show's love triangle may appear contrived to some, it effectively captivates its teenage audience with dramatic twists and engaging character arcs. However, its theatrical and occasionally cringe-worthy moments may not appeal to all viewers, demonstrating the show's specific target demographic and storytelling style.