The sports drama "The Hill" explores the life of Rickey Marshall. Ricky is a preacher's son from Fort Worth, Texas, who beats the odds to become a professional baseball player despite growing up in poverty and suffering from a spinal disorder. Although the film's acting and direction show promise, it falls short of emotional depth and complexity. This makes it an earnest but monotonous journey.
See Also: Strays (2023) - Movie Review
Helmed by Jeff Celentano and scripted by the late Scott Marshall Smith and Angelo Pizzo - known for classics like "Rudy" and "Hoosiers" - the film bears a thematic resemblance to the iconic "Rocky." It highlights an underdog story where the stakes are personal and relatable, not grandiose. Rickey is in his youth by Jesse Berry and as a teen by Colin Ford. Despite physical and financial challenges, Rickey makes it to Major League baseball, if only briefly, testifying to his indomitable spirit.
However, the film's real issues lie in its two-dimensional character development and narrative predictability. In an attempt to cater to a faith-based audience, "The Hill" ends up diluting its substance. This leaves even the genuine human conflicts appearing formulaic. This is evident in Rickey's internal struggle between following his father James' footsteps into ministry and pursuing his baseball dreams. James, played by Dennis Quaid, sees his son’s athletic ambitions as incompatible with spiritual calling, going as far as to compare his son's baseball card collection to "false idols."
What could have been a fertile ground for tension is often relegated to polite disagreements. Even at moments when James opposes Rickey's dreams, the film refrains from delving into the complexities or contradictions that often mark parent-child relationships. This reluctance to show flawed characters limits the movie's emotional impact.
The spark in the narrative emerges during heated exchanges between Rickey and his father on reconciling faith and personal ambition. Rickey argues that his talent can serve God on the baseball field just as it can behind the pulpit. This supports his view with a drawing of a baseball diamond that doubles as a Christian cross. Yet, these insightful interactions don't result in transformative character development.
The film includes other characters who also remain largely one-dimensional. Grace, Rickey’s love interest, is confident but underdeveloped. Appearances by seasoned actors like Scott Glenn, who plays a baseball scout, momentarily elevate the narrative but aren't enough to infuse it with the needed complexity.
The sidelined roles of women characters like Helen, James’ wife, and the hero’s grandmother, further undermine the film’s emotional range. While they could offer layered perspectives, they are often relegated to background roles, diluting their potential impact.
Despite the fascinating real-life story of Rickey Marshall - who now combines ministry with entrepreneurship in the wellness sector - "The Hill" misses the opportunity to offer a nuanced depiction of his life. The real Rickey sees his life as full and meaningful, unfazed by what could be perceived as missed opportunities or setbacks. A documentary might have done more justice to his multi-faceted life, embracing complexities often smoothed over by Hollywood narratives.
"The Hill" could have benefitted from diving deeper into its characters' imperfections and moral complexities, to present a more engaging and relatable human story. Instead, it ends up being a well-intentioned but ultimately unconvincing portrayal. It is much like a competent sermon that lacks the fire to genuinely move its congregation.
