Upon leaving prison early due to a blend of his good conduct and terminal pancreatic cancer, Max (Brian Cox) is in a state of limbo. His old contacts from his days immersed in Las Vegas's criminal underworld still linger. However, he yearns for a life far removed from that. With his remaining days, he strives to rebuild bridges with his estranged daughter Maxine (Kate Beckinsale). Maxine on the other hand, is reluctant to entertain. A single mother, she juggles various jobs to afford the epilepsy medication needed for her son Ezra (Christopher Convery). Having been let down by Max before, she hesitates to allow this belated fatherly affection. Yet, she relents, and Max starts a new chapter living with Maxine and Ezra. Catherine Hardwicke's "Prisoner's Daughter" is an exploration of the ensuing turmoil and potential healing that unfolds.
See Also: The Tank (2023) - Movie Review
Penned by Mark Bacci, the story of "Prisoner's Daughter" can feel formulaic, tracking Maxine's gradual thawing towards her father and the blooming connection between grandfather and grandson. Brian Cox and Kate Beckinsale infuse life into their somewhat underdeveloped roles. They imbue each scene with potent emotions and rich history. Ezra, targeted at school due to his seizures and in need of a paternal figure, is caught between his mother and his drug-addicted father, Tyler (Tyson Ritter). Tyler lives a questionable lifestyle. He characterizes his drug-filled abode as an 'artist's co-op’. He craves a greater role in his son's life. Maxine becomes the villain when she denies him access. Max, now part of the domestic setting, steps in, with varied results.
Effective scripts blend seamlessly into the story, but "Prisoner's Daughter" struggles to achieve this. Its dialogue-heavy nature leaves one feeling more like they're reading the script rather than experiencing a narrative, despite the compelling performances of Beckinsale and Cox. Christopher Convery's character, Ezra, isn't quite as fortunate. The lines assigned to the supposedly 'precocious' child lean towards being overly cute and unrealistic. They suggest a writer who doesn't truly understand children. The unnaturally mature discussions and self-aware quips undermine the authenticity of the dialogue and the film. This issue is underscored by a mismatched final act, where Max takes the reigns, resulting in a story more driven by plot than characters. The result is a disappointing deflation of "Prisoner's Daughter."
Las Vegas, often depicted in films as a glitzy and dangerous playground, houses ordinary people living everyday lives, much like the characters in this film. The film successfully captures the desert city's gritty and appealing attributes. Maxine's modest abode, though dismissed by her as a "dump," is a home she has managed to make cozy despite her strained resources.
One particularly poignant moment is when Maxine interviews for a position in a corporate laundromat. The sheer amazement on Beckinsale's face at the mention of 'health insurance' is a powerful, wordless expression. It's an implicit criticism of a flawed system that ties crucial medical care to employment, an inhumane construct.
Catherine Hardwicke has a knack for capturing the essence of specific scenes and subcultures, as seen in her earlier works like "Lords of Dogtown," "Thirteen," and the first film of the "Twilight" series. Each one highlighted her unique ability to delve into the intimate details of various environments and themes. By comparison, "Prisoner's Daughter" feels rather lukewarm. Despite her best efforts, Hardwicke struggles to create an impactful vibe where the script falls flat. A director of her caliber deserves a project that allows her creative freedom to thrive. With her keen eye for detail, empathetic approach, and atmospheric sensitivity, her next endeavor hopefully offers her the opportunity to showcase her full potential.
