"Genie," the latest offering from Peacock, blends elements of "Elf" and "Aladdin" to create a family movie that initially charms but ultimately fizzles out due to a lack of innovative ideas and a muddled storyline. Despite engaging performances from Paapa Essiedu, Melissa McCarthy, Marc Maron, and Luis Guzman, the film struggles to maintain its initial momentum and ends up as a somewhat underwhelming holiday escapade.
The film centers on Bernard, portrayed by Paapa Essiedu, a hardworking dad who, in his professional zeal, forgets his daughter's birthday, leading to a trial separation from his wife. His woes are compounded when he loses his job to a heartless boss, played briefly by Alan Cumming. Bernard's mundane life takes a whimsical turn when he encounters Flora, a genie played by Melissa McCarthy, who has time-traveled from two millennia ago. McCarthy brings a sense of wonder and humor to her role, marveling at contemporary novelties like smartphones and pizza.
While McCarthy's comedic flair provides some laughs, it soon becomes apparent that her character's development doesn't extend beyond her initial bewilderment. The movie starts strong with energy and humor, but as it progresses, it stumbles into a predictable plot that revolves around using wishes to win back Bernard's estranged wife. This narrative choice is problematic, hinting at the idea that one must change their essence to be a desirable partner.
The film then veers into an odd subplot involving Bernard wishing a Messi jersey into the Mona Lisa, leading to an arrest for art theft – a plot twist that feels out of place in a supposed holiday movie. This deviation further highlights the screenplay's lack of coherence and direction, possibly indicating a rushed or incomplete script from the creator of "Love Actually."
As "Genie" approaches its conclusion, it settles on a clichéd moral: the importance of prioritizing family over work. This well-worn theme of a workaholic realizing the value of family could have been impactful, but it falls flat in a narrative filled with magical wishes and genies. The film's attempt to tug at heartstrings in its final moments may resonate with younger audiences or families where overworking is a concern, but for others, it might come across as too simplistic and uninspired.
In summary, "Genie" starts as a delightful, light-hearted family movie but ultimately disappoints due to its lackluster plot and failure to fully utilize its magical premise. Despite the best efforts of its talented cast, the film struggles to find its footing, leaving viewers wishing for a more cohesive and engaging story.
