In the fifth episode of "Fool Me Once," titled "Awakening Nightmares," the plot thickens as Maya Stern is awakened from a night terror about her late husband, Joe. The episode opens with Maya's friend, Eva, showing up in a panic, afraid that her ex has hacked her nanny camera. This revelation leads Maya to suspect that the footage of Joe on her own nanny camera might have been planted. Despite Shane's investigation into her Wi-Fi revealing nothing suspicious, Maya remains unconvinced.
Detective Kierce updates Maya on the case, but she's left disappointed by the lack of progress. During the conversation, Maya notices Kierce's shaky hands, though he dismisses her concerns. Shane, worried about Maya's mental state, suggests a therapist, but Maya insists she's coping well.
The episode also reveals that Marty has concerns about Kierce's well-being, urging him to be honest with his fiancée, Molly, about his health issues. Concurrently, Alexa, Maya's niece, delves into her mother Claire's past, discovering that their half-brother, Louis, had been secretly connecting with Claire.
Eli, Alexa's brother, uncovers more about their mother's past, including her meetings with Louis and her mysterious visit to a school before her death. As Alexa grapples with this newfound knowledge, she calls Maya, who is visiting Judith, Joe's mother. Maya learns about the connection between Claire and Louis and decides to further investigate the mysterious past events that have resurfaced.
Maya's investigation leads her to Joe's former school, where she learns about a tragic event involving a student named Theo Mora. The headmaster's explanation of the incident raises more questions than answers, hinting at a possible cover-up.
Meanwhile, Kierce faces his own health crisis, with tests indicating a degenerative condition. Struggling with the diagnosis, he breaks off his engagement with Molly and contemplates his future.
The episode culminates with Maya and Corey discovering Tommy's body in a storage unit freezer, indicating a sinister turn in the ongoing investigation. Claire's discovery of a scandal involving Burkett's pharmaceutical company and its deadly antibiotics adds another layer to the complex web of deceit and intrigue.
"Fool Me Once" episode 5, "Awakening Nightmares," masterfully continues to weave a complex narrative, blending personal struggles with a deepening mystery. Each character's actions and discoveries add to the suspense, leaving viewers eagerly anticipating the next revelations in this gripping series.