"Fly Me to the Moon", directed by Greg Berlanti, is an unusual blend of nostalgic romance, biting political satire, and regret-filled drama. This mish-mash of styles cause the film to be somewhat tonally chaotic and stretched over its runtime. Despite the great potential brought by A-list actors Scarlett Johansson and Channing Tatum, the film fails to capitalize on their charisma due to their lack of on-screen chemistry.
Johansson shines as Kelly Jones, a late-sixties advertising executive who is picked to promote the space program. Her character, an energetic blend of charm and intelligence wrapped in stunning mid-century chic costumes, is the standout of the film. Kelly's ability to quickly adapt and manipulate situations is a joy to watch and gives life to the storyline.
However, this spark doesn't translate into her supposed romantic relationship with Tatum's launch director character, Cole Davis. This anticipated romance falls flat and seems out of place for what initially unfolds as a clash of personalities in an unexpected encounter.
The film attempts to capture the witty dialogue and frisson seen in classic rom-coms such as the Rock Hudson and Doris Day classics but falls short. Johansson and Tatum seem to inhabit different cinematic worlds - she's outgoing and daring while he is cautious and restrained.
The inclusion of a conspiracy theory plotline, where Kelly is tasked with hiring actors to stage a moon landing in case the actual event fails, adds a quirky rhythm to the movie but also adds to the plot's complexity. The film's last act is weighed down by protracted twists and turns, with revelations that could have been left subtle or hidden.
Despite featuring talented supporting actors, their contributions are watered down by the thinly written characters. An unnecessary cameo by Colin Jost ad further confusion about the film's genre.
"Fly Me to the Moon" is indecisive in its genre, wavering between humor and serious drama, romantic nostalgia, and historical critique. Its inability to find a clear pathway through these conflicting elements mirrors the chaotic events of the movie itself.
