Based on a factual account, as aired on Chicago Public Radio’s This American Life, "American Dreamer" is a captivating tale by Paul Dektorunfoldig Phil Loder's plight, underscored by Peter Dinklage. He is an economically challenged, thrice-divorced economics professor who longs to be a homeowner - a dream that seems impractical within his financial means. Seizing an extraordinary but unsustainable opportunity, Phil enters into an agreement with Astrid Finnelli, a childless, terminally ill widow, played by Shirley MacLaine. Astrid offers her grand mansion for a pittance. As the storyline unfolds, Phil realises that the offer is too enticing to be true, and discerns the bitter truth about the American dream.
Dinklage’s sterling performance is balanced by the iconic Shirley MacLaine, resulting in a perfect concoction of capricious dialogues riddled with compassion and determination. The portrayal of their characters steals the audience's hearts, inspiring an emotionally stirring response. Their compelling performances form the soul of the movie.
The narrative is further enriched with daring, hilarious stunts, and Dinklage makes his character, Phil, cherishable and identifiable. MacLaine's unabated edgy comic vibe continues to charm the audience. Subtle lines in the dialogue hint at reincarnation, a topic MacLaine has frequently discussed and written about over the years. The movie hosts a well-selected cast including Matt Dillon, Danny Glover, Kim Quinn, and Danny Pudi, each bringing their exceptional flavor to the respective scenes they partake in.